Experts are divided on the
scale of the security risk posed by radio frequency identification (RFID)
wireless tag technology after a computer expert demonstrated that data held on
the tags could be easily cloned.
At the Defcon security
conference in Las Vegas, Lukas Grunwald of German security company DN-Systems
demonstrated a way to copy information between RFID tags, including those used
in new e-passports and corporate access cards.
Grunwald said the technique had
taken just "two weeks and $5,000 in legal fees to develop" using inexpensive
RFID hardware and scanners and homegrown software.
While Grunwald was not able to
manipulate or change data held on the tags - limiting its usefulness for forging
e-passports holding biometric data - the approach did quickly copy data onto new
tags, posing a potential security risk for firms using the technology in
corporate access cards or to authenticate products such as medicines or
manufacturing components.
Nigel Montgomery of analyst
firm AMR Research branded the demonstration as " sensationalist", and said the
security threat posed by RFID tags was still " minimal", but admitted it was
likely to hamper adoption of RFID technologies.
"RFID tags are not 100 percent
secure, but what is?" Montgomery asked. " People could copy data held on tags,
but it is far easier for them to copy a label and a barcode [on counterfeit
medicines, for example] than find the radio frequency, copy the tag and decrypt
it so they can understand what's on it."
However, Roy Illsley of analyst
firm Butler Group said the news showed RFID technology can pose a real security
risk for firms. "The biggest issue is the reader and the tag tend to be at the
edges of organisations, ie in depots, so theoretically these represent soft
entry points into an organisation," he said.
Illsley added that in the
future the tags could provide an entry point for viruses or could be easily
copied, making their usefulness for tackling counterfeit goods "null and void".
Adam Jura of analyst
Datamonitor agreed the ability to clone tags could provide opportunities for
fraudsters, as a cloned tag for an expensive product could easily be attached to
a counterfeit or cheaper version.
Experts agreed firms need to
consider security issues when making RFID deployment decisions. "If you are
talking to suppliers about RFID solutions my advice would be to get your
security experts along as well," said Illsley. "You have to ask questions about
the firewall on the system and how you can limit the risk of duplication."
Separately, IBM today (9
August) unveiled a new RFID system to track pharmaceutical products. The system,
built on IBM' s WebSphere middleware platform, allows pharmaceutical firms to
track products through their supply chain, and can help tackle counterfeit
drugs, and ensure medicines match prescriptions.